Monday, November 28, 2016

Speak English, Please




for fb.jpg   By Florida Bill  

                                             The United States is truly an exceptional nation.  But in its 200 plus years of existence--and I would bet that a lot of people do not know this--no one ever succeeded in making "English" the official language of the country.
                                              Routinely, proposals for "Official English" are introduced in Congress.  There is often a good deal of talk and predictions that it will become law, but ultimately the bill dies until its resurrection in a future session.  It seems like it ought to be a slam-dunk, but it isn't.  
                                              Iowa Representative Steve King has a bill pending in Congress seeking to have English declared as the nation's official language.  His confidence in its passage has increased with the election of President Trump whose has made "America First" a priority with his administration.  
                                              Europe, it might be noted, has some 50 nations and each has its own official language, and I suspect that residents have pride in their homeland, as America does.  Many Europeans actually speak more than one language which often includes English, but in their home territory there is an official tongue.  In Spain it is Spanish;  in France it is French; in Germany, it is German,  and in Italy, it is Italian.  The United Kingdom has declared English as its official language as have some surprising spots like Gambia, Ghana, Liberia, Nigeria, Sierra Leone, Uganda, Zambia, and Zimbabwe.  Official English in many, many places---but not in the United States.  
                                              There are roughly 6,500 spoken languages in the world today.  The most popular tongue is Mandarin Chinese with 1.2 billion persons speaking that language.  If you go to China and insist on speaking a language other than Chinese, and then try to demand government services in your foreign tongue, you won't get too far.  What you will get is the China boot.                         
                                              America is the world's most generous and exceptional nation, where everything is laid out in the Constitution and Bill of Rights--but no language is official.  Thirty-two of the 50 sovereign states have enacted a law declaring English as its official and primary language inside its state lines, and five states currently have legislation pending toward that end.  So why isn't English the official language of the USA, asks King, Congress' most aggressive proponent of English as the nation's official language. 
                                            English is the language used for legislation, regulations, executive orders, treaties, federal court rulings, and all other official pronouncements so why not clear the table and have "English" receive its rightful and legitimate blessing, said King. Then there would be something to back us up when we say to our  legal (and illegal) visitors, "Learn English!" 
                                            Researchers tell us that around 90 per cent of Americans, both Republicans and Democrats, favor the declaration, yet the years pass and legislation is considered, but nothing ever happens.  Somehow, with "political correctness" going full tilt, the idea of requiring immigrants to learn English is seen in liberal corners as a "tool of oppression," bordering on racism.  
                                           Former President Obama believed that immigrants ought to learn English, but he saw a declaration by the nation that English is its official language as sort of unsportsman-like to immigrants. "Nonsense" said King.  English is the dominant language in the USA, and Spanish is second, although depending on where you live, it may seem that order is reversed.   
                                           As a senator from Illinois, Obama voted four times against bills calling for English as the national language.  But he was not alone.  Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden opposed it also, as did more than 30 other senators, mostly liberal Democrats.    It's unfair to immigrants to face this language burden, argues Obama, who has suggested that instead, Americans just learn to speak Spanish and then everyone would be bilingual. 
                                          President Obama stood in real contrast to other presidents, including Pres. Clinton, who favored English as the language of America.  One, in particular, Theodore Roosevelt, had plenty to say on the subject, as he extended a warm and friendly hand to immigrants, but there were caveats. 
                                          "In the first place," he said, "we should insist that if the immigrant who comes here in good faith and becomes an American and assimilates himself to us--  he shall be treated on an exact equality with everyone else... There can be no divided allegiance here.  Any man who says he is an American, but something else also, is not an American at all. We have room for but one flag, the American flag. We have room for but one language here, and that is the English language ... and we have room for but one sole loyalty and that is a loyalty to the American people."   
                                           In recent months, we have heard  President Trump point to the importance of speaking English.          "We will stop apologizing for America, and we will start celebrating America," Trump has asserted. "We will be united by our common culture, values and principles, becoming one American nation, and one country, under one constitution,  saluting one American flag," 
                                           Congressman King, has been a fierce proponent of official "English" in America and particularly when applied to immigrants.  King has argued that establishing an official language like other countries would bring consistency and unity. With the new President, whose patriotism and love of country is worn on his sleeve, and who has said that under his administration, "America will come first,"  there is increased optimism that "English" will at long last become the official language of the United States.  Correspondingly, immigrants would be obligated to speak English if they are to assimilate into the American way of life. 
                                                xxx

                                     



                                   
        
             
                                                   
                                               

                                             
            

1 comment:

  1. Thanks for the update on where the English-language movement -- if there is one -- stands. I think, however, that it's too late, like closing the proverbial barn door after the cow has fled. We are in fact already just like Canada, a bi-lingual nation whee today all product packaging, most legal and financial documents, much public signage and even commercial telephone greetings are in two tongues. If there ever is language legislation, it will -- as in Canada -- confirm two official languages.

    It's fact of life. History will record the Mexican War as a campaign that was won in a war that was eventually lost, as Mexico gradually re-invaded the US over a period of many years. then flooded-in as border controls relaxed more recently. Most of these people will assimilate while retaining their native values, as most migrant groups have
    in the past. The best the Trump administration can do is stem the tide, secure the border, deport as many criminals as possible, eliminate "sanctuary cities," establish a clear path to citizenship (including taxes and civics education), and enforce existing immigration and hiring laws. Trump will build a wall of both physical and high-tech barriers, and will make Mexico pay for it through tariffs, economic sanctions and re-negotiating NAFTA.

    But the Spanish language is part of our culture now. Accept it, and use it.

    ReplyDelete